What Survey Issues Should I Expect on Anna Maria Island?

Why AMI Surveys Matter More

Anna Maria Island is a seven-mile barrier island straddling Manatee County and the cities of Anna Maria, Holmes Beach, and Bradenton Beach. Most parcels are small (50–80 feet of frontage on average), bordered by neighbors, and near or directly on the Gulf or bay. Small lots plus high land values plus decades of informal improvements (fences built to the “wrong” side of a property line, sheds encroaching into setbacks, seawalls shifted over the years) make survey issues common.

Title insurance does NOT cover survey issues unless you pay for the enhanced owner’s policy or order a new survey and the policy is endorsed based on it. A basic owner’s policy excludes “matters which an accurate survey would disclose.” Translation: if the fence turns out to be three feet over your line, title insurance won’t help you fix it unless you specifically endorsed the policy.

Issue 1: Boundary Discrepancies

The recorded plat and the reality on the ground often disagree. On AMI, typical discrepancies:

I’d like to share my thoughts about Eric. He spent parts of two days showing me condos in Anna Maria, Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach. Because of the upfront work we did together leveraging the Internet, each condo that we viewed together was one that I wanted to see. No time was wasted. Eric’s approach was not only very professional but also personable! He is very knowledgeable of the local market. In addition, he is a very nice young man and a value to Team Renick. I encourage everyone that wants to use their time most efficiently to reach out and give Eric a call. I fully expect to make my purchase decision in the next two days!

– Alice Lipski, Google Review

• Fences built 1–3 feet inside or outside the actual property line (can create adverse possession claims after 7 years under F.S. 95.18)
• Seawalls that have shifted 6–18 inches from original placement over decades
• Hedges and landscaping that extend across the line
• Driveways or paver installations crossing onto the neighbor’s parcel
• Pool decks, lanais, or accessory structures placed before current setbacks
• Corner monuments missing, disturbed, or replaced incorrectly

A proper boundary survey locates the four corners of the lot (or more on irregular parcels), references them to the recorded plat, and draws the improvements (house, pool, dock, fence, driveway) to scale. Any discrepancy between the recorded line and what’s actually there is flagged on the survey.

Remedies for boundary issues range from agreed boundary-line agreement recorded with neighbor (relatively cheap, $1,500–$4,000 with attorney), to quiet title action (expensive, $5,000–$15,000+), to encroachment removal (varies widely). None of these get cheaper by waiting.

Issue 2: Setbacks and Coastal Construction Control Line

Every AMI jurisdiction has zoning setbacks (front, rear, side) that new construction must observe. Older AMI homes often predate current setbacks and are legally non-conforming. Non-conforming structures can usually stay, but:

• You can’t expand them beyond the existing footprint in the non-conforming area
• If damaged above 50% of structure value (FEMA 50% rule), you may have to rebuild conforming
• Renovations may trigger full compliance review

The Gulf-facing side of AMI is subject to Florida’s Coastal Construction Control Line (CCCL), administered by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. The CCCL is a regulatory line that runs parallel to the coast and requires a special permit for any construction seaward of it.

For any real estate needs Team Renick is the only way to go! They are responsive, professional and always put their clients first. My family and friends all use Team Renick and have had the same fantastic experience. 5 start all around!

– Sarah Bosco, Google Review

Issues on CCCL parcels:

• Existing structures seaward of the CCCL may be non-conforming or permitted under old variances
• Renovations seaward of the CCCL require DEP review and permit — 3–12 month process
• Storm damage repair over 50% triggers CCCL compliance review
• New construction seaward of the CCCL requires engineering, habitat assessment, and often mitigation

A survey should plot the CCCL in relation to the improvements. If your seawall, pool, or deck is seaward of the CCCL, you have a compliance file on record that travels with the property.

Issue 3: Undisclosed Easements

Easements are rights that someone else has to use part of your land. On AMI, common ones:

• Utility easements (typically 5–10 feet along property lines for power, water, sewer, cable)
• Drainage easements (critical on AMI — stormwater flow must be preserved)
• Beach access easements (public, quasi-public, or neighborhood rights across private land to the beach)
• Riparian rights easements (submerged land leases, dock permits, boat slips)
• Shared driveway easements (more common on older north-end AMI parcels)
• Prescriptive easements (created by long-term use, not recorded — only surveyor inspection or neighbor interview catches them)

Easements should appear on the title commitment (Schedule B-II exceptions) AND be depicted on a current survey. If a 10-foot drainage easement runs across the back of your lot, you can’t build a pool there. If a beach access easement crosses your front yard, you can’t block it with a fence. Title insurance covers undisclosed easements that existed at closing but not disclosed easements.

Types of Surveys in Florida

Survey Type	What It Shows	Cost (2026, AMI)
Boundary Survey	Corners, property lines, improvements, fences	$500–$900
Florida Standard Survey (Boundary + improvements + encroachments)	Full residential survey	$600–$1,500
Elevation Certificate	Flood zone, base flood elevation, structure elevation	$400–$700
ALTA/NSPS Land Title Survey	Detailed commercial-grade survey including Table A items	$1,500–$4,500
Mortgage Survey (lender required)	Minimal — just corners and house footprint	$350–$550
Specific Purpose (e.g., tree, topo)	As-needed	Varies

For a residential AMI purchase, order a Florida Standard Survey during the inspection period. For commercial or investment properties, or for any parcel with complex boundary or easement issues, order an ALTA survey. Most AMI lenders accept a Florida Standard Survey for loan purposes.

When to Order

Order the survey as soon as the inspection contingency starts — not at day 10 of a 14-day window. Surveyors are busy on AMI in 2026, and lead times are typically 7–14 business days. If the survey uncovers an issue, you need time during the inspection period to:

1. Verify the issue with a second surveyor or title attorney
2. Price the remedy
3. Negotiate with the seller (repair, credit, endorsement, or termination)
4. Decide whether to proceed

All of that takes 7–10 business days. Ordering the survey at day 10 of a 14-day inspection period gives you maybe one business day to respond — not enough.

Survey Endorsements on Title Insurance

Your title insurance policy can be endorsed to cover specific survey matters for an additional premium:

• Florida Form 9 endorsement (Restrictions, Encroachments, and Minerals) — covers many survey matters; $25–$150 premium
• Survey Coverage endorsement — specific coverage for matters shown on a current survey; $100–$400
• Enhanced Owner’s Policy — broader coverage than standard; adds 10–15% to premium

Discuss endorsements with your title agent at policy issuance. They’re much cheaper to add at closing than to retrofit later.

Survey Issues That Kill or Reshape AMI Deals

Deal-killers I’ve seen on AMI:

• Pool built entirely within a drainage easement — must be removed for future drainage work
• Seawall 4 feet inside neighbor’s property — neighbor refuses to sign boundary agreement
• Prescriptive beach access crossing the property that the seller didn’t disclose
• Accessory dwelling unit (ADU) with no CO and no legal zoning basis
• CCCL violations where the existing seawall sits seaward of the control line without proper permits
• House footprint 2 feet across the rear setback, blocking a pool or lanai addition

Most survey issues are negotiable or resolvable — but only if caught during inspection.

AMI Jurisdiction-Specific Notes

• City of Anna Maria (north): strict short-term rental regulations; CCCL issues on Gulf side; tight setbacks
• Holmes Beach (middle): most restrictive short-term rental rules on AMI; older neighborhoods with common boundary drift
• Bradenton Beach (south): generally more permissive; more new construction; bay-side parcels often have dock/slip issues

What I Do on AMI Surveys

I order a Florida Standard Survey on day 1 of the inspection period, review it with the buyer and the title attorney, flag anything that shows up in Schedule B-II exceptions, and negotiate endorsements or remedies during the inspection period. On waterfront parcels, I’ll also order an elevation certificate and check the CCCL line position from DEP. The combined cost is $1,000–$2,000 — small money on a $1M+ AMI purchase to catch the things that would otherwise become your problem.

To learn more about Michael and Team Renick
To search for local properties: search.teamrenick.com
To read more insights: blog.teamrenick.com