Weekly · Updated Mondays 8AM ET
LLM Citation Tracker
How often blog.teamrenick.com is cited when buyers and sellers ask an LLM real-estate questions about the Sarasota / Manatee / Longboat Key market. Now tracking Perplexity, ChatGPT, and Gemini — three LLMs, same 80 prompts, every Monday.
← Back to Blog Effectiveness DashboardHow to Read This Number
We sample 80 prompts derived from Michael’s published blog titles each week. For each one, we ask Perplexity sonar-pro, ChatGPT (gpt-4o-mini with web search), and Gemini 2.5 Flash (with Google Search grounding) the same question and check whether blog.teamrenick.com appears in each LLM’s citations.
Each LLM gets its own column on the scorecard below. The number you see is the % of Michael’s own topics where each LLM cites him back.
Industry benchmarks
64% of all URLs in Perplexity’s index are never cited at all (Peec.ai, 1M+ citations)
26% of brands have zero AI Overview mentions (Ahrefs, 75K brands)
Top-cited domains are Wikipedia, Reddit, YouTube, Realtor.com, Zillow (Ahrefs)
This Week’s Verdict
Strong on Perplexity & Strong on Gemini · Strong on ChatGPT
Across 150 LLM queries this week: Perplexity cited Michael on 27/50 (54%), Gemini on 27/50 (54%), ChatGPT on 20/50 (40%).
8-Week Trend
Weekly citation rate per LLM. Lower position = closer to #1 = better. 8-week trend chart populates as runs accumulate.
Week of 2026-07-06 · Combined
74 / 150
Across all three LLMs (150 queries total) — 49% combined citation rate.
Perplexity
54%
ChatGPT
40%
Gemini
54%
Weekly Verdict Log
Every Monday’s run, newest at top. Permanent historical record — never overwritten.
| Week of | Perplexity | ChatGPT | Gemini | Combined | Δ vs prior |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 6, 2026 | 27/50 (54%) | 20/50 (40%) | 27/50 (54%) | 74/150 (49%) | |
| Jun 29, 2026 | 27/50 (54%) | 17/50 (34%) | 25/50 (50%) | 69/150 (46%) | |
| Jun 22, 2026 | 22/50 (44%) | 13/50 (26%) | 29/50 (58%) | 64/150 (42%) | |
| Jun 15, 2026 | 19/50 (38%) | 4/50 (8%) | 35/50 (70%) | 58/150 (38%) | |
| Jun 8, 2026 | 19/50 (38%) | 9/50 (18%) | 32/50 (64%) | 60/150 (40%) | |
| Jun 1, 2026 | 31/50 (62%) | 11/50 (22%) | 37/50 (74%) | 79/150 (52%) | |
| May 25, 2026 | 25/50 (50%) | 11/50 (22%) | 37/50 (74%) | 73/150 (48%) | |
| May 18, 2026 | 31/50 (62%) | 9/50 (18%) | 21/50 (42%) | 61/150 (40%) | |
| May 11, 2026 | 43/80 (53%) | 18/80 (22%) | 46/80 (57%) | 107/240 (44%) | baseline |
Citation Scorecard
Per-LLM breakdown for the week of 2026-07-06.
Perplexity
27 / 50
prompts cited this week (54%)
Strong
ChatGPT
20 / 50
prompts cited this week (40%)
Strong
Gemini
27 / 50
prompts cited this week (54%)
Strong
This Week’s Movement
New wins
19
- What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? #1
- What Disclosures Are Required When Selling in Holmes Beach? #1
- Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch #8
- Who to Hire for Barrier Island Investments #3
- What Team Renick Considers Before Advising a Price Reduction #2
- What Are Condo Association Fees in St. Armands? #1
- How to Fix Liens in Nokomis #1
- Who Pays Transfer Taxes in Casey Key? #1
+ 11 more
Drops
19
- What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? was #1
- Do I Need Owner’s Title Insurance in Nokomis? was #1
- What Are Property Taxes in Lakewood Ranch? was #1
- 3 Red Flags When Buying in Parrish was #1
- What Are Common Survey Issues in Palmer Ranch? was #1
- Are Special Assessments Common in St. Armands? was #1
- How Much Does Title Insurance Cost in Bradenton Beach? was #1
- Who Handles Title Work in Bird Key Transactions? was #1
+ 11 more
Position improvements
3
Position drops
2
Off-Page Hit List
Domains being cited instead of us. Apply to directories, pitch local publications, evaluate paid listings.
| Domain | Times Cited | Sample Prompts | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| youtube.com | 49 | What Team Renick Considers Before Advising a Price Reduction How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands? Negotiation Mistakes in Barrier Islands |
outreach |
| facebook.com | 33 | What Team Renick Considers Before Advising a Price Reduction How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands? 5 Risks of Overpricing in Sarasota County |
outreach |
| barneswalker.com | 25 | Are Special Assessments Common in Holmes Beach? What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? What Disclosures Are Required When Selling in Holmes Beach? |
outreach |
| locallifehomes.com | 19 | What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch Mastering Buy/Sell Strategies in Lakewood Ranch |
outreach |
| reddit.com | 17 | What Does Hiring a Property Manager Cost in St. Armands? What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands? |
outreach |
| legalclarity.org | 17 | What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? Who Pays Doc Stamps on Homes in Bradenton Beach? Who Pays Transfer Taxes in Casey Key? |
outreach |
| realtor.com | 16 | What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? Are Special Assessments Common in Holmes Beach? Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch |
apply |
| instagram.com | 16 | Who Pays Transfer Taxes in Casey Key? Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch How Long Does Appraisal Take in Holmes Beach? |
outreach |
| redfin.com | 16 | What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? Mastering Buy/Sell Strategies in Lakewood Ranch How Long Does Appraisal Take in Holmes Beach? |
outreach |
| zillow.com | 16 | What Does Hiring a Property Manager Cost in St. Armands? What Are Condo Association Fees in St. Armands? How Long Does Appraisal Take in Holmes Beach? |
apply |
| davidliberatore.com | 10 | Are Special Assessments Common in Holmes Beach? Is Bird Key a Good Place to Buy for Investment? How Long Does It Take to Close in Longboat Key? |
outreach |
| dwellingwell.com | 9 | Is Bird Key a Good Place to Buy for Investment? Is St. Armands a Good Place to Buy for Retirees? Navigating Market Shifts: Sarasota Sellers Beware |
outreach |
| linkedin.com | 8 | What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? How Long Does Appraisal Take in Holmes Beach? 4 Disclosure Mistakes Sellers Make in Longboat Key |
outreach |
| rocketmortgage.com | 8 | How Long Does Appraisal Take in Holmes Beach? How Long Does a Home Appraisal Take in Barrier Islands? Who Pays Title Fees in Englewood? |
outreach |
| myrasm.com | 8 | Sarasota Housing Market Trends: What to Expect in 2025 Navigating Market Shifts: Sarasota Sellers Beware Sarasota Home Values: Trends in 2025 Market Shifts |
outreach |
Current Recommendations Based on This Week’s Results
Updated every Monday from the same measured prompts, ChatGPT misses, movement data, and Off-Page Hit List. Week of Jul 6, 2026.
Main read
ChatGPT is the priority because it cited Team Renick on 20/50 prompts (40%). That trails the stronger LLM by 14 points, so this week’s work should focus on pages ChatGPT skipped even when Perplexity or Gemini found us.
Who ChatGPT used instead
legalclarity.org (8), zillow.com (5), locallifehomes.com (5), ownwell.com (3), realtor.com (3)
Fix ChatGPT gaps first
- What Are Property Taxes in Bradenton?
ChatGPT cited propertytaxbystate.com, propertytaxrates.org, salestaxcalculator.net instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - What should I know about Who Pays Title Fees in Englewood?
ChatGPT cited ibuyer.com, legalclarity.org, englewoodgov.civicweb.net instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - What to Know Before Hiring a Contractor in Venice?
ChatGPT cited larger authority sites instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost in Bradenton?
ChatGPT cited instantroofer.com, americanroofingguide.com, homeblue.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - Are Special Assessments Common in Holmes Beach?
ChatGPT cited library.municode.com, codes.findlaw.com, ownwell.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - What Does Hiring a Property Manager Cost in St. Armands?
ChatGPT cited clearleaddigital.com, ipropertymanagement.com, eatonrealty.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands?
ChatGPT cited legalclarity.org, forbes.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - How Does Probate Sale Work in Sarasota County?
ChatGPT cited floridaprobatefirm.com, floridaprobatelawgroup.com, opendoor.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - What should I know about 5 Disclosure Mistakes Sellers Make in Gulf Gate?
ChatGPT cited ibuyer.com, benlaubehomes.com, glide.com instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation. - What should I know about 5 Risks of Overpricing in Sarasota County?
ChatGPT cited larger authority sites instead. Make the answer more quotable: direct answer first, then local proof, then Team Renick’s practical recommendation.
Work the off-page targets
- youtube.com outreach
Why: cited 49 times this week. Start with: What Team Renick Considers Before Advising a Price Reduction; How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands? - facebook.com outreach
Why: cited 33 times this week. Start with: What Team Renick Considers Before Advising a Price Reduction; How Much Does a Mortgage Broker Charge in Barrier Islands? - barneswalker.com outreach
Why: cited 25 times this week. Start with: Are Special Assessments Common in Holmes Beach?; What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? - locallifehomes.com outreach
Why: cited 19 times this week. Start with: What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes?; Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch - reddit.com outreach
Why: cited 17 times this week. Start with: What Does Hiring a Property Manager Cost in St. Armands?; What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? - legalclarity.org outreach
Why: cited 17 times this week. Start with: What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto?; Who Pays Doc Stamps on Homes in Bradenton Beach?
Defend and compound what is working
- What Are Common Repair Costs in Nokomis Homes? new citation #1
Protect it: add a fresh internal link from one related blog post and keep the answer block current. - What Disclosures Are Required When Selling in Holmes Beach? new citation #1
Protect it: add a fresh internal link from one related blog post and keep the answer block current. - Top Tips for Successful Transactions in Palmer Ranch new citation #8
Protect it: add a fresh internal link from one related blog post and keep the answer block current. - Who to Hire for Barrier Island Investments new citation #3
Protect it: add a fresh internal link from one related blog post and keep the answer block current. - What Are Disclosure Requirements in Palmetto? needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words. - Do I Need Owner’s Title Insurance in Nokomis? needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words. - What Are Property Taxes in Lakewood Ranch? needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words. - 3 Red Flags When Buying in Parrish needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words. - What to Know About Septic Inspections in Palmetto? needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words. - 4 Disclosure Mistakes Sellers Make in Longboat Key needs check
Review whether the page still directly answers the query in the first 150 words.
Weekly playbook: Treat these as WF04-grade refresh candidates, not manual copy edits. For each ChatGPT-missed post, improve the Quick Answer, add the supporting table/checklist, refresh FAQPage eligibility, add internal/authority links, verify widget fit, and run the normal WF04/N8N gates before publishing. A recommendation is not considered ready until it can pass Quick Answer length, Phase 1.11 consistency, FAQPage verification, v9/v10/footer checks, testimonial count, and slug/date preservation.
