Buying or selling? Know who holds the power before you negotiate.
Every month we measure the balance of negotiating power between buyers and sellers in 14 Sarasota & Manatee communities — computed from live MLS data, explained in plain English. This is the work a strong agent does before the conversation.
The islands belong to buyers. The mainland is even.
Every dot is a community — the farther right, the more power buyers hold there. Four communities give buyers a clear edge, eight are an even match, and Lakewood Ranch is the firmest market on the coast. One caution if you’re buying: June’s sales pace ran ahead of seasonal norms in most communities. The leverage is real — but it isn’t growing.
The verdict, community by community
Who has the edge, and what to do about it — whether you’re making the offer or fielding it. Open “the math” on any card to see exactly what drives the reading. Sorted by buyer leverage, most to least.
See the math behind this reading
- 21.0 months of homes for sale at the current 90-day buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 55.8% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 87.8% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median sale took 119 days over the last 90 days vs 43 in the 90 days before
- Closings over the last 90 days ran 79% of this community’s seasonal norm
See the math behind this reading
- 7.5 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 65.2% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 88.0% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 86 days vs 60 in April
- June closings ran 90% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 7.6 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 50.0% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 86.2% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 79 days vs 67 in April
- June closings ran 101% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 9.1 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 53.9% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 86.8% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 73 days vs 64 in April
- June closings ran 134% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 4.7 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 54.6% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 88.1% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 54 days vs 40 in April
- June closings ran 112% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 4.5 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 53.0% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 89.7% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 44 days vs 50 in April
- June closings ran 108% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 5.0 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 55.8% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 87.3% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 78 days vs 91 in April
- June closings ran 136% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 7.4 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 51.9% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 89.3% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 80 days vs 136 in April
- June closings ran 124% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 3.7 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 54.9% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 91.2% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 43 days vs 46 in April
- June closings ran 103% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 3.1 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 51.7% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 91.2% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 50 days vs 49 in April
- June closings ran 107% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 4.1 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 49.8% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 91.1% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 34 days vs 50 in April
- June closings ran 95% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 3.6 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 60.3% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 91.6% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 28 days vs 46 in April
- June closings ran 103% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 3.5 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 59.2% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 94.4% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 47 days vs 46 in April
- June closings ran 117% of this community’s seasonal June norm
See the math behind this reading
- 2.0 months of homes for sale at June’s buying pace (about 6 is even)
- 49.6% of active listings have already cut their asking price
- Homes closed at 92.5% of the seller’s original ask (12-month average)
- Median June sale took 27 days vs 23 in April
- June closings ran 135% of this community’s seasonal June norm
Mangrove Realty Associates Inc.
What the data can’t tell you, I will
The headline this month is the barrier islands. Holmes Beach reads 79 — the most buyer-favorable monthly reading on the coast — with 65% of its sellers already cutting price. Siesta and Lido aren’t far behind, and across the islands homes are closing 12–14% under original ask. If you’ve been waiting for island leverage, it’s here.
The mainland is a different conversation. Lakewood Ranch is the firmest market we measured — two months of supply and June sales running 35% above the seasonal norm. Parrish sellers are closing at 94.4% of original ask, the strongest ratio on the coast. Balanced doesn’t mean soft.
And here’s the part that surprised me: June got faster almost everywhere. Most of our 13 scored communities closed at or above their seasonal pace. Buyers hold real leverage on this coast — but the direction of travel says don’t confuse leverage with unlimited time. One more honest note: Bradenton Beach carries its first reading this month — a 92, scored on a 90-day window under our new small-market rule, because one June closing isn’t a monthly market. The leverage is real. The market is thin. Negotiate the property, not the average.
Measured the same way, every month, in the open
Five ingredients from live MLS data, one weighted reading per community: months of supply (30%), share of sellers who cut price (20%), what homes actually closed for vs. original ask (20%), how fast the market is moving (15%), and sales pace vs. the seasonal norm (15%).
Stay up to date with Michael
Never miss a Monday.
One short note a week — the coast worth loving, and a plain read on the market. Unsubscribe with one reply.
You’re on the list.
Check your inbox — a note from Mike is on its way.
First reading lands Monday morning.